Somebody in your office will get this email in the next few weeks. It is worth reading before they do, because the version that works isn’t the one people expect.

It is from the head. It is short. It is urgent, and slightly apologetic about being urgent. And it asks for something just outside the normal process — a payment brought forward, a supplier’s bank details updated, a gift card bought quietly for somebody’s leaving present.

The name at the top is right. The address underneath it is not.

We’ve seen this in multiple schools across Staffordshire and Cheshire this year alone.

Why it works

Most phishing advice is about spelling and dodgy formatting. That advice is a decade out of date. The emails are well written now, and the ones aimed at schools have usually been researched — the head’s name, the business manager’s name, and the fact that term has just started.

What actually makes it work is the shape of the request. It uses authority, urgency, and a small deviation from process, all at once, aimed at somebody trying to be helpful in a busy office. That is not a technical weakness. It is an entirely reasonable instinct being used against you.

Four tells

  • The display name matches, but the address does not. Phones show the name and hide the address, which is exactly why these arrive first thing in the morning.
  • The urgency has no reason attached. Real urgency comes with a because — the deadline is Friday, the supplier is chasing. Manufactured urgency is just pressure.
  • It moves you off email. “I’m in a meeting, text me on this number.” Once you are on WhatsApp, none of your email protections applies.
  • It asks you not to mention it yet. A surprise, a confidential matter, something being handled quietly. This is the tell that should end the conversation.

The rule that beats all four

That is the whole policy. Verifying requests on a known number helps staff feel confident in their actions, reducing uncertainty and building trust even when emails seem convincing.

That is the whole policy. It fits on a sticky note, and it works even when the email is better than the four tells above — which, eventually, one will be.

The reason to write it down rather than rely on judgment is that it empowers staff to act confidently. A written rule makes checking routine, reducing hesitation and fostering a proactive security culture.

If somebody has already replied

First: nobody is in trouble. If that is not obvious in your school, it’s important to create a safe environment where staff feel comfortable reporting incidents promptly, fostering responsibility and trust.

  • If bank details were changed or a payment was made, ring the bank immediately. Speed matters more than anything else here.
  • If a password was entered, change it from a different device and check whether the account has forwarding rules set. Attackers add them so they can keep reading after the password changes.
  • Tell the head and whoever holds IT. If money is involved, report it to Action Fraud.
  • Tell the rest of the staff what happened, without naming anybody. If one person got it, several did.

The thing worth doing this term

Put the verification rule in writing using a simple template, tell the office team it exists, and emphasize that checking is always encouraged and supported.

That takes about ten minutes, and it is worth more than any amount of software.