Password managers get recommended to schools constantly, usually without anybody asking the question that matters: for whom?
The honest answer is that they are clearly worth it for some people in your school and close to pointless for others, and the usual pitch skips that distinction entirely.
Who should have one
The office team, the business manager, and anybody holding admin accounts. These are the people with the most logins, the highest-consequence ones, and — realistically — a list somewhere they would rather not tell you about. A password manager replaces that list with something encrypted, shareable and revocable.
The shareable part matters more than people expect. Shared mailboxes, the catering system, the parent communication platform: a manager with a shared vault means you can hand over those credentials when somebody leaves, rather than reset them in a panic.
Who probably should not bother
A teacher with two or three logins that single sign-on already covers does not have a password problem. Giving them a password manager adds a tool to solve a problem they do not have, and unused tools become shelfware that somebody still pays for.
Roll it out to everybody, and you will get low adoption, a support burden, and a renewal invoice in twelve months for licences nobody opened. Roll it out to fifteen people who genuinely need it, and it works.
The question nobody asks
What happens if the person holding the vault leaves, or forgets the master password?
A password manager concentrates risk beautifully. That is the point, and also the danger. Without a recovery route, you have swapped a messy problem — passwords scattered about — for a sharp one: everything in one place that nobody can open.
- Use a business or team plan with a recovery route, and ensure multiple administrators are designated, to mitigate risks and reassure staff about password manager security.
- More than one person should have administrator rights—ideally two, not in the same family or the same car.
- Write down where the recovery kit is stored, and keep it somewhere that isn’t inside the password manager.
What it costs
Per user, per month, and modest. The number is usually not the obstacle — the obstacle is that it is a per-user subscription in a budget line that doesn’t have one yet, which makes it feel bigger than it is. Cost it for the group who need it rather than for the whole staff, and it is a small figure.
Check before you buy: your existing platform may already include something. Both Microsoft and Google have moved in this direction, and the school may already be paying for it.
Where it sits against multi-factor authentication
If you can only do one this term, do multi-factor authentication. It stops the attack that is actually happening to schools right now — a password stolen through a phishing email and used the same afternoon.
A password manager makes good passwords possible. MFA makes a stolen password much less useful. Both are worth having, in that order.